Phil Steele Review, Part One: Positional Rankings
The venerable Phil Steele's annual preview guide is out, and I got my grubby hands on a copy. We're not ready to start talking nationally just yet, but it's never too early to talk Texas.
If you've ever read Steele's guide, then you know how packed with information the thing is. We couldn't possibly review his Texas section with just one post, and won't try to. This is the first of a series, and we'll start with his national positional rankings.
Positional Rankings
Not surprisingly, a healthy number of the Longhorns projected starters find themselves ranked among the nation's best, but there are some surprises. Steele's positional rankings include the following Longhorns:
Brian Orakpo (#40, DE)
Eddie Jones (#47, DE)
Aaron Lewis (#54, DE)
Frank Okam (#2, DT)
Roy Miller (#5, DT)
Rashad Bobino (#11, ILB)
Robert Killebrew (#12, OLB)
Sergio Kindle, (#29, OLB)
Cedrick Dockery (#11, OG)
Tony Hills (#18, OT)
Adam Ulatoski (#57, OT)
Colt McCoy (#22, QB)
Jamaal Charles (#6, RB)
Jermichael Finley (#18, TE)
Limas Sweed (#1, WR)
Billy Pittman (#35, WR)
Quan Cosby (#54, WR)
Projected Texas starters not ranked: Charlie Tanner, Dallas Griffin, Marcus Griffin, Drew Kelson, Deon Beasley, Brandon Foster. (We'll grant Steele that he believes Kindle, Bobino, and Killebrew will be the starting LBs.)
Commentary: These rankings illustrate both why a national preview magazine is inevitably going to miss a little bit, as well as why if you're going to buy just one of these national books, Steele's is the one.
On defense, Steele is appropriately enthused about Okam and Miller, but leaving Lokey off the list altogether will (in this blogger's view) prove to be something Steele regrets... Steele's Defensive End rankings look fair, and he's insightful to slip Jones up ahead of Lewis. I see that coming to pass before '07 is done... Listing Robert Killebrew as the 12th best OLB in the country is borderline criminal; he was a giant disappointment last season... If he stays healthy, Roddrick Muckelroy may be All-Big 12 before this season is done - Steele's going to regret not listing him anywhere... I can't say I disagree with Steele's decision not to list any member of Texas' secondary in his rankings. Where the Texas DBs are experienced, they are flawed. Where they are uber-talented, they are young and inexperienced. It's going to be a(nother) interesting year.
On offense, Steele's offensive line rankings fall in line with the conventional wisdom of Longhorn fans: Hills and Dockery are strong players, but beyond that, there are big questions... Colt McCoy at #22 looks low to me, but Steele may be hedging his bets to some extent here. McCoy does have durability issues following the stinger injury. Still, my view is that this offense is going to be focused on Colt and the receivers as the primary weapon. (Oddly, in the Texas section, Steele notes that he likes McCoy to improve on his ridiculous freshman numbers. Doesn't seem totally consistent with his QB ranking, unless it's an injury hedge... Cosby and Pittman should be reversed in their rankings. Pittman's a very talented receiver, but Cosby and Colt have a silly connection building. I wouldn't blink if Cosby approached a Texas single-season receptions record... Finley at #18 will prove to be a mistake. He's about to take a Big step forward, and is practically unguardable already.
--PB--
0 recs |
13 comments
Comments
horns
I agree on switching Quan and Pittman. No knock on Pittman, but as you observed Colt and Cosby have started to develop some nice chemistry. I'm also considering his value on kick returns, which is probably unfair when comparing with other WRs.
I also agree on Colt and Finley being too low, but maybe I need to read the whole thing to see who is listed above them.
by SelimSivad on Jun 15, 2007 11:00 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Above Colt
In order:
Brian Brohm
John David Booty
Colt Brennan
Andre Woodson
Chad Henne
Erik Ainge
Chase Hoolbrook
Matt Ryan
Nate Longshore
Graham Harrell
Chase Daniel
Bobby Reid
Curtis Painter
Anthony Morelli
Paul Smith
Pat White
Sam Keller
Drew Weaterford
Tim Tebow
Kyle Wright
Stephen McGee
by Peter Bean on Jun 15, 2007 11:02 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
McGee?
The list above him are all people who can complete a pass. How the hell did McGee get put ahead of colt?
by cliffaudit on Jun 15, 2007 11:05 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
McGee
His numbers turned out better than he actually looked at times throwing passes. Final '06 stats:
194-313 (a healthy 62%), 2295 yards, 12 TD, 2 INT
Rushing: 146 carries, 831 yards (4.6 ypc), 4 TD
That's a strong season, even if he throws some truly bafflingly ugly passes at times. McGee's a gutty leader, too. The Aggies should have a formidable offense for the first time in ages, with talent at the skill positions and a deep, experienced line.
It's the defense that looks like Trouble.
by Peter Bean on Jun 15, 2007 11:10 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Ok but how can that be compared with McCoy
217-318 68.2% 2570 yards, 29 TD, 7INT
Do the rushing for McGee include sacks?
Colt has 68 att for 170 net, 2.5 yd 2 TD (He had 13.1 yards per gain, but the stats are lower due to the sacks)
by Wells on Jun 15, 2007 11:48 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
ok
what a joke - I would put Colt up in the top 5 of that list easily... maybe behind Brohm and the other Colt. Morelli? Are they serious?
by SelimSivad on Jun 15, 2007 11:13 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Morelli
only starts, because they don't have anyone else.
He is quite possibly one of the worst QBs I've ever seen play.
Bobby Reid had more completions to Longhorn fans in the stands than he did his own teammates. Quite literally. His best pass of the game was to Michael Griffin.
by EYESofBEVO on Jun 15, 2007 11:46 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
That list is a joke
A few of those guys may not even be the starters on their own teams.
Phil needs to put down the pipe and seek some help.
by EYESofBEVO on Jun 15, 2007 11:44 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
you know I'm not an unbiased observer
but that list is a joke
I'd put Brennan ahead of Booty. Booty is a fine QB, but he isn't a difference maker, imo. He manages the game and makes some nice plays, but he won't make 'the play' to win the game; Brennan does that.
I'd put Brohm behind both of them.
Of those listed, my list would look something like this:
- Colt Brennan
- John David Booty
- Chad Henne
- Brian Brohm
- Chase Daniel
- Stephen McGee
- Pat White
- Colt McCoy
- Tim Tebow
- Andre Woodson
- Bobby Reid
- Graham Harrell
then everyone else.
Kyle Wright ranks about #110 on the list of top D-IA QBs. He is quite possibly the worst college QB I have ever seen.
by Beergut on Jun 15, 2007 4:20 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Colt
I find the whole thing rather odd as to why Colt is so low, because before he got injured last year he had played his way into the heisman race in most peoples books... How does doing that as a freshman translate into anything but a top 5 qb rating the next season?
by PrewCary on Jun 16, 2007 12:06 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
injuries is my only guess
I would be willing to bet that is going to be the lowest you're going to see McCoy rated in any pre-season magazine.
by Beergut on Jun 16, 2007 1:36 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Sweed
I think Limas is going to make everyone forget who wore #4 originally. Glad to see Steele is giving him respect, because most of the other rankings I've seen put him in the top 10 at best.
One of the many things I love about Limas shows up in this pic.
Jamaal is clearly on his way in to score against Rice, but Sweed is still looking for someone to block, just in case. This guy has come so far since his freshman year. I hope he has a record-breaking final season.
by patienthornsfan on Jun 17, 2007 2:36 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
























