The Definitive Case For Will Muschamp, Part 2
This post started as Morning Coffee, but my first bullet quickly spilled over brief note territory to a sprawling in-depth treatment. I may do a third part to this series tackling some of the particulars I said in Part 1 would be the focus of Part 2. Today, though, how three sentences from Brian Orakpo spoke to the heart of my enthusiasm for the Muschamp retention plan.
About two hours after the final regular season BCS Standings were released, Mack Brown and three veteran team leaders (Quan Cosby, Colt McCoy, and Brian Orakpo) sat down and soldiered through the "How does it feel?" routine with the press. Texas' trio of representatives dutifully walked through uncontroversial statements which surely undersold their true level of frustration and disappointment.
Though the "How bad does it sting?" portion of the program read straight from a script, the news conference featured one nugget that leapt out at me: Brian Orakpo called 2008 his "favorite season" as a Longhorn--a notable characterization on Day of Snub, and from no less than a 2005 national title winner. In elaborating, the words Orakpo naturally drifted to were "fun" and "team." The first thought that popped into my mind was that Orakpo's sentiments were validation of the remarkable turnaround commitment from Mack Brown following last year's disaster in College Station, an immediate, multi-stage effort impressive in many regards--none bigger than the decision to demote Duane Akina and hire Will Muschamp.

Among the many reasons to support the Muschamp successorship decision, Orakpo's spirit speaks to the heart of why I so strongly believe this was the right move with the right coach at the right time. Even in the preseason, his practice habits and explanations to the press of his philosophies gave me great hope this coach was every bit worthy his reputation. He implemented heavy contact hitting in spring drills (including a daily Hard Hat Award for the player who laid the best lick in practice) and by August, Texas linebacker Rod Muckelroy was telling reporters that Muschamp's legendary onni-presence was literal: Texas' new defensive coordinator had begun to invade Muck's dreams. By kickoff of the season opener, all the early signs indicated Texas had on its staff exactly the right coach to fully actualize everything Mack Brown thought needed improving after things bottomed out against Texas A&M.
There has been throughout this season a discernable, bonded commitment to Team and all the responsibilities that come with it, manifest in countless little ways that count--be it Lamarr Houston insisting he make right on his mistake by apologizing to both the team and local press or Texas' trio of tailbacks unwaveringly supporting each other in a split-duties situation. Accountability, genuine love of and support for teammates, and a "You go, we go" selfless pursuit of collective goals have been on display all season long. I don't think it at all a coincidence that this is the first Mack Brown Texas team since 1998 to exceed expectations. The 11-year Longhorns head coach deserves a lot of credit for his aggressive approach to righting the ship, elevating in priority a no excuses, you're-with-us-or-you're-out attitude, bringing in Major Applewhite, and making the Muschamp for Akina swap at DC.
RECALLING THE PAST. THEN BURYING IT.
Of all the wonderful accomplishments and developments of this year's team we've talked about throughout the season, arguably the most critical is something we're not talking about: Vince Young. Three years removed sometimes seems an eternity in a fan's world, but speaking as someone deeply entrenched in Texas football fan discussion I can assure you not only that Vince Young (the player, the entity, the centerpiece of QB recruiting theories, and on and on) dominated Longhorns discourse in 2006, 2007, and not infrequently leading up to 2008 (See: Shepherd, R. vs Gilbert, G.), but the Vince Young absence/lingering-presence phenomenon extended far past bleacher banter and was a real component in various ailments of the 2006 and 07 Longhorns football teams.
This season has made it so easy to forget those post-VY identity problems that meaningfully hamstrung Texas' last two squads that I even feel a little rusty writing about him, but now is an appropriate time to make official note that the leadership vacuum after Vince's departure is now a part of history. Though no one feared a post-VY malaise would hover over the program indefinitely, the particular problems Texas suffered from the last two years and their resolution in 2008 raise several relevant points worth exploring in some detail.
LEADERSHIP YOU'RE BORN WITH
It's not uncharitable to say Vince Young was the missing puzzle piece Mack Brown needed to summit the mountain. My personal take has always been that while Mack needed VY to get to the very top, he got there, which is what he was supposed to do. Champagne toasts all around, yes? If only. There of course have been lingering critics who try to cheapen Mack's accomplishments with "Yeah, but VY," an objection I think totally misses the forest for the trees. If 2005 wound up Mack's only mountain summit, as far as I'm concerned his tenure would still have to be considered an overall success.
With that said, it sure felt last November like Texas either needed another once-a-decade player and, more importantly, superior leader like Vince Young, or else Mack Brown's last 5-8 years in the program might well hover in that 'very good but not great' zone. Though much of the fan obsession with Vince Young even after his departure was a natural consequence of his mindblowing feats on the field, beneath that fandom there was also an urgency among fans to find someone who could play and lead like Vince had. If Mack's harshest critics were outspoken in trying to use Mack Brown's success with Vince Young againsthim, unspoken among many Texas fans was an unsettling anxiousness to find the next do-it-all difference maker.
As Texas fans understood well, the importance of the kind of leadership Vince Young provided can't be overstated. It's critical for every team with aspirations of top prizes, and for the 95% of teams whose head coaches, like Mack Brown, don't posses it themselves, the ability to identify, recruit, develop, and utilize those rare players is pretty much the name of the game. While Mack Brown is a masterful orchestrator, much tougher than most realize, and far more sophisticated and intelligent than you'd expect if all you knew about him was his chosen public relations style, Mack Brown has plenty of meaningful leadership skills. But they are of a different kind than those which people like Vince Young provide, and which is an integral component of every football team which manages to summit the mountain.
I walk through all that set up to help illuminate how enormously exciting and important it is that the 2008 team has filled the post-VY vacuum. Part of it is McCoy (who if perhaps is not quite a VY-level team leader is a capable one in his own right). Part of it is the fruit of the tree Mack Brown planted during bowl workouts last year, marking a clear and decisive shift in priorities. Part of it is the new program-wide hyper-commitment to elevated standards of accountability and the like (a great example being Ken Rucker's new position). An exhaustive list would note a host of other positive contributing developments.
But none, I'm confident speculating, are as important as has been the Muschamp hire. Elite leadership (in the Vince Young sense) of a college football team is of the kind that I suspect you're either born with or not. Mack Brown is overflowing with a host of other important leadership skills, but not that natural on-field, team elevating, we'll gladly go to war and fight any army of any size on any day, kind of fire and charisma Texas was treated to with Vince Young and suffered without the past two years. Listening to the players talk, observing some of the changes in preparation, and watching the cohesion and unified spirit with which this team competes look to me very much like direct or indirect beneficiaries of the return of that kind of leadership. I only blog the freaking team, and I would go to war with Will Muschamp. Listening to the way they play together and talk about their fearless leader, God knows what the actual players would do.
It's been obvious from the first day he arrived in Austin that Muschamp is one of those rare special leaders and I very much believe Muschamp's contributions from his leadership style have extended well beyond his ability to teach defense, permeated countless aspects of the team and staff preparation and execution, and on a daily basis elevated and reinforced the absolute highest goals and expectations--a feat he achieves both in by his own example and through other manifestations of his natural, infectious, charisma and leadership.
Even if I'm overstating his importance (and I don't think that I am), there is no question whatsoever that Mack Brown's decision to pursue and hire Muschamp was the single best thing he could have done to support and further the new attitude and goals fundamental to the turnaround he was trying to orchestrate. If Muschamp "only" served that purpose during his tenure, it would have been a damn important contribution. But this is much, much bigger than that.
THAT WAS JUST YOUR APPETIZER, SIR
Assume if only for the remainder of this post that I'm right about Muschamp's particular leadership gifts that particularly help a college football team. If true, Mack Brown not only did the single best thing he could have to support a rally in the short-term, but now, with the coach-in-waiting hire, Texas football may well be set for years and years to come. While it's wonderful to bottle a genie like Vince Young for four years, the real jackpot is landing that rarest head coach who does well all the things coaches are supposed to do but also on his own possesses that particular kind of charisma and leadership that inspires and gets the very most out of individual players and the team they comprise.
Frankly, 95% of the reason I'm not totally devastated by this year's BCS bullshit is because I 100% believe the Texas football program is far and away the strongest it's been in my lifetime. Better even that 2005, which was as great a season as we could ever hope to have, but depended very much on Vince himself, which obviously is a winning formula with a very short shelf life. A successful head coach can last for decades.
The Muschamp hire ideally reinforced Mack Brown's short-term turnaround goals, was critical in this team's thirlling and unexpected 11-1 run, and led to a long-term agreement that will keep Muschamp in Austin and eventually put him at the helm, a move I obviously think outstanding. And while we're here, think about this, too: Though I'd be surprised if Muschamp-as-successor was considered by Deloss and Mack much or at all prior to his hiring, even if it had I would bet the farm that the overwhelming/probably the only reason Texas made this offer was because of what he's shown in just 9 months on campus. As Deloss Dodds recently said (and many of you pointed out when the successorship was announced), "We are the Joneses." Applied to this situation, I translate the job offer as, "We only are doing this because we believe this guy is nothing short of excellent in every important way."
Though I suppose there may be some Muschamp skeptics among the faithful--justifiable given his lack of head coaching experience--every single thing I seen from and learned about Will Muschamp over the last year has not just reinforced, but furthered, my enthusiasm for and belief in what he offers as a college football coach.
And that's why today, when I might otherwise be moping and bitching and harassing my way through the Big 12 snub, I remain in relatively good spirits, awfully excited about where this program is and appears to be headed, and thankful, even, for back-to-back losses to A&M in 2006-07--without which Texas probably does not pursue Muschamp, potentially coasts along in 'very good not great mode,' and has no set plan for Mack's replacement when he steps down in 2-3 years.
FUN. OH, RIGHT. THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE FUN
Don't forget that Orakpo quote the next time you get into a good conversation with a buddy about this 2008 Texas football season. Underneath all the important and impressive things that have factored in its success is the abundance of Team unity, cohesiveness, spirit, and... yeah, fun.
Hey, don't kid yourself: While fun may not sound like something coaches can just whip up on a whim amidst all the grueling work required to prepare for and play through a college football season, that's because they can't. Fun isn't something you plan and coach; it's a byproduct of a unified team that's happy to be working hard together.
Don't just take my word for it, though. Think back to the last time a Texas football team was both working harder than everyone else and always seeming to be so loose and happy about it all.
Oh, yeah.... 2005. That Vince Young guy. You remember him, don't you?
0 recs |
19
comments
| Add comment
Read Related
Comments
amazingly written
And I agree 100%.
I am interested in your further thoughts, since this essay covered mainly the Muschamp “positives.” It still remains to be seen whether Muschamp can emulate and build upon Mack’s core strengths: recruiting, successful CEO management, and gathering booster support. Most importantly, Muschamp has never before been a head coach; can he succeed having to manage everything, and not just the 11 men on defense?
by jc25 on
Dec 1, 2008 10:39 AM CST
reply
0 recs
we are only a few years away from a couple of National Championships
I think the most important thing that Will brought to the table is credibility. I mean if you could turn around last year’s defence to what it has done this year, I can only imagine what every 5 star recruit in Texas is thinking right now. People will get recruited just to be coached by him..
Although its just my opinion, I foresee that Texas in a couple of years will have the kind of Defence that LSU had last year, and the kind of Offence that we had in 2005. With Garrett Gilbert showing the kind of playmaking ability that Colt has provided so far, we are in for a treat over the next decade…
Remember, before the start of this season, pundits all across ESPN and SI had projected that this would be the first year that Texas did not have a 10 win season…. HA!
by Crimson Fog on
Dec 1, 2008 10:58 AM CST
up
reply
0 recs
Excellent post, but
I take issue with one characterization. We are not the Jonses. We’re Texas.
by mnHorn on
Dec 1, 2008 10:53 AM CST
reply
0 recs
So much FUN
This Texas team captured me like no other. It was the feeling of rebuilding at the beginning of the year, heightened expectations after the RRS, excitement after Missouri, relief after OSU, nervousness before and what-if after Tech, helplessness down the stretch, and finally hopefulness turned into harsh reality about 3:15 yesterday.
It’s the fact that this team OVER-achieved that pleasantly surprised all of us. Running backs by committee, what we thought was lack of playmaking at WR, puppies all over the secondary, a difficult Big XII, etc. This team was tough, resilient, confident, relaxed, and fun all at the same time.
I missed family functions, birthdays, and time I probably should have spent with my wife and son to be in front of the TV for games against OU, Missouri, OSU, and Tech. I could not turn away even for a minute. I had to be there. I dreamt about football games a couple of nights ago. It consumed me. I sat at the computer for a couple of hours yesterday afternoon refreshing sites and awaiting the BCS results.
These guys deserved this and it hurts.
And the fact is this – they aren’t here without Mack Brown. I loved to hate Mack for being conservative, sticking with Greg Davis, being too nice, not getting the best out of potential, not developing a tough, scrappy team, etc.
He got it right in a big way. He changed. He developed. He hired Muschamp. He put the best players on the field. He let Greg Davis do what he does best. He became mega-CEO, kept the fast clap, and you can’t argue with the results. The guy is awesome. Last year I might have traded him for Carroll or Stoops or Meyer. I just don’t know if those guys could do any better in representing the team and the University. In fact, I know they couldn’t.
Not anymore.
I can’t wait for 2009.
by jtlonghorn on
Dec 1, 2008 11:18 AM CST
reply
0 recs
Thanks, PB.
It’s been a rough 24 hours, but this does give this season some perspective.
Hopefully we will look back on this season not for what could have been, but for what began.
by ctex80 on
Dec 1, 2008 11:19 AM CST
reply
0 recs
Dangerously obsessive
I don’t know about the rest of the “BONizens”, as PB likes to call us, but the events leading up to this glorious season, as editorialized above, put me on a “live and breathe” everything Texas Football for the past 11 months. Sad to say, but my whole world has changed in those 11 months. While I have always been a whatchacallit fan, I cannot get enough of anything and everything Texas Football. From What’s on first to Who’s on 2nd to I Don’t Know on 3rd….the whole 9 yards. Work, Eat, Sleep, Texas Football; Work, Eat, Sleep, Texas Football; every day. It’s a wonder my wife has not left me and it’s a good thing she adores me adoring the Horns.
The fact that I can come here everyday and express joyously and emotionally my feelings and adoration is a real blessing, or maybe, I just need help.
Whatever it is, I just “Jones” everyday. God bless Texas and God bless our Horns!
And thanks PB, as always, for the perspective.
by TXStampede on
Dec 1, 2008 12:11 PM CST
reply
0 recs
Well, your wife always knows where you are. hehehe
And I’m sure she can get your attention when she needs it. You have a great deal to appreciate.
by whills on
Dec 1, 2008 1:11 PM CST
up
reply
0 recs
So what you're saying is...
… we have the potential to create not only one of the strongest programs in the country (which we already are), but the long-term strategy and personnel to win for as far into the near future as we can foresee… and the catalyst for all this, the person we have to thank for saving us from years of being a good-to-fair ballclub…
…is Aggy??
by Heart of a Muschampion on
Dec 1, 2008 12:18 PM CST
reply
0 recs
Things do work out for the best, don't they?
One of the powerful points of our experience right now is that the Horns have built up some great karma. When the football gods turn away from you for a while, they will give back at the appropriate time. We should be confident and humble in our path.
by whills on
Dec 1, 2008 1:14 PM CST
up
reply
0 recs
Agreed
I have never had as much fun during a college football season as I have this year. We might have gotten screwed by a ridiculous Big 12 system at the very end, but never before have I lived and died so faithfully with this team. I would march with Mack, Muschamp, Colt, ‘Rak, Cosby, and the rest of this team to the gates of hell and back. I’m thrilled to have been a part of this team.
Also, I really like how PB pointed out the team cohesiveness that ‘Rak pointed out in the conference. It’s not something you can find anywhere, and it’s not something that this team had in the past two years. It’s invaluable to have a team that is so committed to itself and the players on it; so much heart. This is a team in the truest sense of the word.
by The Mack Attack on
Dec 1, 2008 12:19 PM CST
reply
0 recs
Can you spell JUGGERNAUT?
I like this post, I agree with all that’s said in it. For those who haven’t put it into words, have you noticed how we don’t seem to fumble at critical times any more? We don’t have (as many) completely BLOWN coverages anymore? We don’t have critical interceptions at critical times anymore (TT’s Charbonnet excepted)? We don’t have critical penalties (except for defensive over exuberance variety) anymore? We don’t have DB’s taking bad angles on running plays anymore?
That’s the thing that was missing from 2006-7 teams. Texas has always had fantastic athletes. But to have this many fantastic athletes continually under-achieve is so frustrating. To have to sit there as receivers run down the field wide open over and over again. Or you’re going in for a touchdown to take the lead and fumble. Or you’re in the red zone and throw a pick. Ok, now it may happen once or twice, but then it GETS FIXED.
I’ve read on other posts that worry UT may come out flat against a team in the Fiesta or Sugar bowl. Do you really think that would happen? And with Mack and Mus, don’t you see what an opportunity this is? We’ve been SLIGHTED! It’s just like PB says. Thank you Aggies for waking us up the last two years to what was wrong so it could get fixed. We’ve progressed a lot this year, but still we could have done better. So now, we can thank the BCS and the Big 12 for giving our coaches yet another fantastic motivational opportunity.
Do you think Blake Gideon will EVER drop a sure interception again? No, I don’t think so. Do you think Colt will forget to check off Ogbannaya in the flat because he thinks Charbonnet will be there instead of jumping the slant Shipley’s running? No, I don’t think so. Do you think the DB’s will give up on a play because somebody blows a whistle in the stands at an away game? No, I don’t think so.
These are all things people whine about in these blogs because they cost us in the short term, this year. But guys, we are going to really be strong next year. Who wants to play Texas now? The team that beat OU? The team that came back on the pretenders, Texas Tech? The team that throttled Missouri? The team that played the toughest four game stretch in 20+ years and went 3-1?
And after they lost at TT, had to come back and play Baylor. How many of you, in the back of your minds, was going “Oh no. This is not going to be good. Mentally, this has to be tough. They’re going to come out flat.” And they throttled Baylor after the TT loss.
That was when I knew, we’ve got a really good team. Because it’s not as much the athletes and their abilities. IT’S THEIR MINDS AND PSYCHOLOGY. And that’s where the Muschamp leadership factor really comes into play. PB is dead on. Having extrardinary player leadership is great, but it’s short term. Player leaves, leadership leaves. Having extraordinary coaching leadership is great and it’s long term and it’s bigger than just one player.
So, the bowl game and starting next year, UT should be the unstoppable juggernaut of the college football world. It will be very interesting to watch. And if by some sort of BCS magic we can go to the big show this year, it will just be icing….
by calonghorn on
Dec 1, 2008 1:10 PM CST
reply
1 recs
I agree with you
But only if you answer this…is Colt coming back? I mean, for sure coming back? Now that he is looking into his draft status, I am nervous. He said that he would only leave if it was for the first or second round, and:
“NFL draft expert Mel Kiper projects the 6-foot-3-inch, 210-pound junior as a third- or fourth-round pick if he declares after this season.”
But still, you have to wonder…
If Colt comes back, the team will be incredible. With Grant, Hales and the other redshirts, and guys like Whaley coming in combined with another year for this years’ remaining crew, we will be primed for a run. And Colt will get to work with GG for a year as well.
Hook ’Em!
by hoogs on
Dec 1, 2008 9:46 PM CST
up
reply
0 recs
I've said it before
While the 2005 team is unquestionably the better team (among the greatest to ever walk on to a college football field), this 2008 team, if they indeed win a national title (now a remote goal, but I can hope), may have done something more impressive. That 2005 team was a perfect blend of both upperclassmen leadership and talent, and we steamrolled through most of our schedule. This team did not have the superstars or the hype but they were winning anyway.
It saddens me to see that the love of football seems to have left Vince Young; that’s what made him great. I hope he finds it again, because when he had it, he was something special.
by TheElusiveShadow on
Dec 1, 2008 4:06 PM CST
reply
0 recs
Thanks PB
This brought me out of my current depression.
by GoComets! on
Dec 1, 2008 4:43 PM CST
reply
0 recs
I am not so sure about Akina
Akina probably was not demoted. From the little he said and from what appeared in print last spring he wanted out of the DC job. He was more than ready to get back to his DB job and working with special teams.
The problems we had last year were do in large part to a disaster of a LB coach.
by 71grad on
Dec 1, 2008 5:01 PM CST
reply
0 recs
Our Defense
Has far exceeded my expectations. But I think they could use some tackling practice before whatever bowl game we go to. Tackling in the A&M game could have been better for sure.
On an unrelated note, did anyone else think we started off slow on offense in the Aggy game? And is that GD’s fault or what?
by mrbubbles812 on
Dec 1, 2008 8:09 PM CST
reply
0 recs
If Colt doesn't come back, push the plan to 2010
Hoogs has a point. If Colt doesn’t come back, then we have to wait another year for either Chiles to mature or GG to gel. See, this is the refining year, the year we work out all the kinks. If Colt goes, then the offense will have an adjustment period. Would Chiles have the same off-season work ethic to sit in the film room with Greg, and run 7 on 7 all summer to get the timing down? Even so, that wouldn’t start to come together until mid-next season. GG needs a year, then a gel year.
You saw how long it took Colt to reach this level. 1st year, going good, durability problem. 2nd year going good, mental (pushing it too hard) problem. 3rd year going great, no problems at all as far as QB.
This year has been the defensive working out the kinks year. Freshman starting D-backfield. It’s now been seasoned and is ahead of schedule. Linebackers ok, only on spot (I think) graduating. D-Line will miss Rak.
The only thing that needs fixing is…..running game. If you take this year’s team and keep it at 90% of current performance, but fix the running game with a 100+/game back, we’ll be scary good.
It’s a brave new world out there for the ‘horns. We’ve always been near the top with 10 win seasons and the like, but now we’re going to be at the top of the USC/OSU/OU/FL multi-year dominance club. Multi-Year Big 12 Championships. Multi-Year National Championships. It should last around 4-8 years. It will be a sweet time.
by calonghorn on
Dec 2, 2008 12:47 PM CST
reply
0 recs
Nagging fear
PB, well done. I’m sitting here this morning, fearing what Paul Harvey famously characterized as “the rest of the story.”
I’ve read twice now, and sure it’s anecdotal but it looks like high degree of confidence anecdotal, that Muschamp has been offered separately the Washington position, and now the Auburn position.
These ‘offered’ positions may be totally unfounded, but it just makes me wonder how long we can hold on to Muschamp. Sure, he’s giving Mack Brown assurances, but we know how these coaching searches can turn out – and you can’t provide full disclosure to your boss when entertaining new opportunities.
Sign me “Fear & loathing in Houston.”
by HalfmileHorn on
Dec 5, 2008 11:41 AM CST
reply
0 recs















