Searching For Six -- The Wide Receiver Position Battle, Part I
Bobby Kennedy and Greg Davis have the unenviable task of finding trimming the 12-man receiving corps down to a six-man rotation, leaving the other six on the outside looking in for the 2009 season. With the intense competition and burgeoning skill of the young receivers and emergence of James Kirkendoll, Malcolm Williams, and Brandon Collins, the task may seem nearly impossible, but the four apparent locks will help make the decision-making easier for the coaches.
The Locks
Jordan Shipley - Did you know that his father roomed with Colt's dad in college? Or what about that little-known fact that he and Colt are roommates and close friends? What about the next generation: Colt's little brother Case and Jordan's little bro Jaxon? Did you know about them? No? Well, now you do, and knowledge is power. It's fitting to begin an analysis of Shipley with sarcastic comments, as there isn't much more to say about the finally-healthy receiver and Great White Hope.
The coaches may move Shipley around in the offense this season to get favorable match ups, much as they did with Quan Cosby in the Fiesta Bowl in an attempt to avoid Malcolm Jenkins. Since Malcolm Williams is widely expected to provide the long-lost deep threat in 2009, the least likely position for Shipley to see much time is at split end, but Shipley is capable of playing flanker and both slot positions in the offense. An analysis of Shipley is incomplete without mentioning his incredible ability to come into and out of breaks, making him one of the best receivers, if not the best, at executing double moves in college football, an ability made possible by his short strides.
Perhaps the biggest question with Shipley is how much he will return punts and kicks, which could wear him down within games and over the course of the season, a concern heightened by the nature of the offense, which demands a great sacrifice of the body on nearly every underneath pass to holes in coverage that close quickly and with violence. Clearly, his two touchdowns in the kicking game were monumental last season, coming as they did in crucial portions of the game -- after going down two scores against Oklahoma and helping to spur the comeback bid in Lubbock.
Malcolm Williams - In the NFL, three years is the conventional wisdom for how long it takes for a receiver to truly understand and excel in the professional game. That conventional wisdom isn't as prevalent in college, but it would make sense for the adjustment to a higher level of play to be relatively consistent across levels. As Williams enters his third season in the offense, he's expected to provide the big-play threat missing since Limas Sweed suffered his eventually season-ending wrist injury during fall practice in 2007. To the end of establishing that deep threat, Williams has worked hard in the off season with Colt McCoy in an attempt to establish the same connection that McCoy had with Sweed, efforts that Williams also made after the Oklahoma game that led to his impressive catch in traffic against Missouri.
The other big expectation for Williams is that he will consistently catch the football, an issue during bowl practice that kept him out of the game against Ohio State. After hard work during the spring to rectify the problem, Williams has been catching the ball much more consistently and earned the starting split end position over Dan Buckner in the process.
As coaches try to protect Jordan Shipley from injury, Williams could see time returning kicks, flashing his ability in the spring game with an electric kick return that would have gone the distance had it not been for Earl Thomas having the angle on the play.
Brandon Collins - The former basketball player has taken some time to adjust to the physical mentality of football, but most importantly, it has taken time for Collins to understand the work necessary to succeed. For Collins that means working hard to add strength to his thin frame and spending more time in the film room breaking down defenses and understanding and executing his blocking assignments.
Excellent in the screen game, Collins will be expected to build on the flashes of big-play ability shown multiple times in the season, but never more importantly than on the second-to-last play of the Fiesta Bowl, making a tough catch and returning quickly to the line of scrimmage even with an injured ankle. Of all the receivers for Texas, Collins might be the most explosive and able to make defenders miss in space, a skill that could help him see time at split end making the same short catches made in 2008 by Quan Cosby.
James Kirkendoll - The Round Rock product doesn't have the pure speed of Brandon Collins or the physically imposing stature of Malcolm Williams, but he does impress with his consistency and versatility. Known for running consistently crisp routes and understanding his assignments, Kirkendoll is a quarterback's best friend and looked to be establishing a connection with Colt McCoy over the final part of the season, most spectacularly on his tough fourth-down catch against Ohio State on the final drive, without which Quan Cosby never has the chance to end his college career with a game-winning dive into the end zone.
Kirkendoll's steady play will make it difficult to keep him off the field, potentially sending Brandon Collins to the bench in stretches. Showing off his continually-improving connection with Colt McCoy, Kirkendoll made another important fourth-down catch during the Spring Game, converting a 4th-and-17 by making a Texas defender miss in space, an ability he showed in flashes last year, but that the coaches hope he will show more consistently during his junior season.
The Where-Does-He-Fit Player
Dan Buckner - The most highly regarded of the four 2008 receivers, Buckner's biggest moment on the field in 2008 probably came against UTEP, as he failed to fight a jam at the line of scrimmage causing Colt McCoy to throw an interception in the end zone. It wasn't all negative for Buckner, as he caught a long touchdown pass in mop-up duty against Missouri, but the big-bodied receiver still needs to work on his quickness off the line of scrimmage, as explosiveness has never been his best attribute.
Stuck behind Malcolm Williams in the battle for the starting split end job, Buckner's best chance to see the field may come in the flex slot position DJ Grant was playing in the spring before his ankle injury. Buckner saw time at the position during the Spring Game and may be part of the answer as the offense searches desperately for a receiver to stretch the field from the tight end position. Much like Grant, the major question about Buckner at that position revolves around his ability to block. Much like Grant, the coaches would likely only ask Buckner to block the linebackers and safeties matched up against him in that position, rather than lining up on the line of scrimmage and having to block defensive ends. He may, however, be asked to crack block defensive ends, the task in which DJ Grant was engaged when he rolled his ankle.
0 recs |
32 comments
|
Comments
JC
I really hope that his career at UT isn’t a complete bust. Redshirting his freshman year would have really been beneficial.
by PineypointG on Apr 8, 2009 1:03 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Redshirting him this year might be just as beneficial
Especially considering our coaches seem intent on not giving WR’s much playing time until they get down all of the “nuances of the position”.
Seriously, when was the last time we let a WR go out and just make plays based on his amazing physical talents, when he was a little green with understanding the full offense? Roy Williams?
by Horncasting on Apr 8, 2009 2:08 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
The flanker position Chiles is going to play
suits itself to a guy going out and just making plays, as you suggest, since so many screen plays utilize the flanker.
by GhostofBigRoy on Apr 8, 2009 2:31 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
As an addendum
I think the coaches are mostly focusing on a player being in the proper position, especially important when so many teams blitz and, last season, to limit turnovers because the defense wasn’t causing any.
Furthermore, the coaches also demand an understanding and commitment to the blocking game, since the numbers are often difficult when in the shotgun spread. Added to that, the outside zone play often requires the running back to almost reach the sideline before turning upfield — easily blown up if a player on the outside misses their block.
by GhostofBigRoy on Apr 8, 2009 2:33 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Not disagreeing with any of that
Just saying that it would be nice if we could simplify things a few times a game for at least one position/player and see what he can do. I’m convinced we’d be hearing the same things about why Dez Bryant wasn’t getting much playing time if he’d come to UT.
by Horncasting on Apr 8, 2009 3:42 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Malcom Williams
For all of the talk about him having issues with drops in practice, it sure hasn’t shown in any games that I can think of. In fact, in his limited chances last year he made some of the most amazing catches of the year – the one against Mizzou and the one in the Fiesta Bowl where Colt led him a little too much out of bounds (basically the same thing that happend in the spring game).
by Horncasting on Apr 8, 2009 2:12 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
He dropped a pass early in the Tech game.
But you are right, I think that was the only drop that I recall, unless you want to count the deep ball against OU that would have been a great catch.
by GhostofBigRoy on Apr 8, 2009 2:30 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
He did have a great catch in the 3rd against Tech
Basically got us back into the game at that point
by future_longhorn_dad on Apr 8, 2009 2:44 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
The Shipley-Williams combo has the potential to be sweet
If Williams can turn into the deep threat we hope, it’ll put tremendous pressure on defenses trying desperately to stop our short passing game led by Shipley. To make matters worse for them, Shipley has more ability than Cosby had going deep himself, while Malcolm has shown that he can be dangerous with shorter passes as well (Tech game). If safeties pay too much attention on Williams, Shipley might just zip right by. If teams play off of Malcolm too much, he can burn them with something short.
Crap, we need to get a dangerous running game. Then defenses are just screwed unless Colt just has a bad day.
And I know firsthand that Shipley’s double moves are sick. I tried guarding him in basketball in middle school and I felt my ankles would fall off.
by TheElusiveShadow on Apr 8, 2009 2:34 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Shipley/Cosby
Just curious what you are basing this one:
Shipley has more ability than Cosby had going deep himself
If just pure speed, I’d have to disagree after the combine numbers Cosby put up.
by Horncasting on Apr 8, 2009 3:35 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
It has more to do with speed
Shipley’s quickness allows him to shake his defender and get loose more regularly.
As far as speed, I’m under the impression that Cosby’s low 40 time was in the mid 4.4s and his high was in the mid 4.5s, and he’s listing as having a 4.5 forty. I thought Shipley consistently ran in the 4.4s. At least when it comes to the football field, my eyes tell me Shipley possessed more speed, but i could be wrong.
by TheElusiveShadow on Apr 8, 2009 4:23 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Shipley looked like an airplane not a ship
Another classic line from Dave Lapham.
by Meekrob on Apr 8, 2009 4:35 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
It's a tough call on this I think
because both of them have exceptional short-range quickness, as I mentioned with Shipley, he’s aided by his short strides, as is Cosby. I might have to call it a virtual tie, with Shipley having the advantage with his patented double moves.
by GhostofBigRoy on Apr 8, 2009 6:48 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Does anyone know Kirkendoll's middle name?
I refer to him as James T. Kirkendoll (or Captain James Tiberius Kirkendoll when I’m feeling especially excited) and am hopeful that this matches his actual initial.
by Meekrob on Apr 8, 2009 2:43 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Wow, please tell me this is not a Star Trek reference
-rBr-
by run Bevo run on Apr 8, 2009 3:26 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I must be really bored
his middle initial is “P” – sorry to disappoint you, but love the ST reference!
by SelimSivad on Apr 8, 2009 4:42 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
really?
I was interested to see if I could find it, so I looked at MB-TF.com at his bio, and his nickname is JT Kirk. Maybe he likes Star Trek too?
by vy til i die on Apr 8, 2009 5:03 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I just looked
at the UT directory, publicly-available info. Could be wrong, of course, but that’s what it said.
by SelimSivad on Apr 8, 2009 5:07 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
props for the Star Trek reference
off topic, but did you hear about the surprise sneak preview at the Alamo Monday night?!
by crocodile235 on Apr 8, 2009 4:43 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Nice analysis, Big Roy
I like this kind of stuff . . .
My suspicion is that Williams got limited chances last season because of the coaches’ concerns over his practice drops. The failure to go deep may have been more based on likelihood of success than play-calling preference. That’ll change.
I love what Collins and Kirkendoll bring to the table, and what they can be. Sky’s the limit in the passing game as long as Colt is taking the snaps. Strongly second what Shadow said about the running game.
by edsp on Apr 8, 2009 3:45 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
I've thought about that as well,
in terms of the relatively low-percentage nature of throwing deep. If Colt can complete 80% of his passes, then why get yourself in a situation to get into second or third and long situations. That’s what the running game is for.
I agree, though, I think it is a preference and one that will change as the Longhorns look for more big plays.
by GhostofBigRoy on Apr 8, 2009 6:49 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Attrition at WR
Presumably some of the transfers and the attrition that will have to occur is going to come the WR group.
by Arroyo Grande on Apr 8, 2009 8:30 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
'Fraid so.
Coupla of the juniors-to-be aren’t in the mix and aren’t going to be . . . . D.J. Monroe, well, maybe he’ll pull off an academic Hail Mary.
by edsp on Apr 8, 2009 9:09 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Malcolm Williams
I believe Williams can be a Dez Bryant type of player, are they similar in athletic ability or is Bryant superior to Williams?
by PineypointG on Apr 9, 2009 11:04 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs

by 



























