Snap Shots: Garrett Gilbert Uses His Feet
I managed to get my hands on a video of last night's game, which definitely provides a better look at a number of things than did my vantage point in the stands. I haven't sat down to watch it all just yet, but even before I do I wanted to highlight a couple of illustrative plays from the game.
First up, Garrett Gilbert, who looked awfully stiff and mechanical throughout a very slow start over the game's first 20 minutes. But if you're looking for a turning point, it came at the 9:45 mark of the 2nd quarter, when on 3rd and 2 Gilbert scrambled out of the pocket, made a nifty cut-step, turned up field and rushed for 24 yards for a first down at the Rice 36. That play seemed to help get him going, as he started to play much looser and better from that point forward.
In fact, it showed up just two players later, on 2nd down and 4 from the Rice 30, when Gilbert found himself under pressure... (Click any picture to enbiggen.)
Gilbert lines up in the shotgun with four wide receivers and a tailback set to his left. The Texas offensive line from left-to-right goes LT Trey Hopkins, LG David Snow, C Dominic Espinosa, RG Mason Walters, RT Paden Kelley.
Just after taking the snap, Gilbert appears to have a nice pocket, except that after taking the initial pop from the rusher he's assigned to block, David Snow is slow to reset and loses position, suddenly having to reach to try to hold his block. Not happening.
Just like that, Snow's lost him and Gilbert's pretty pocket is about to rapidly dissolve.
As Snow's man officially breaks free and starts in on the quarterback, the rest of the line has held up well and Gilbert is doing a nice job of keeping his head up and surveying the entire field.
Gilbert does a great job of sidestepping the oncoming pressure, and still keeps his head up and eyes downfield as he does so, which allows him to spot Darius White, highlighted on the bottom of the screen.
Gilbert uses his feet to buy time and space, while Darius White does a really nice job of recognizing the situation and breaking hard to the outside.
As White creates separation and the defense closes in, Gilbert tosses a catchable ball to White on the outside, who hauls in a first down on a broken play. Colt McCoy used to do this kind of thing all the time, and after Gilbert broke his big run in the 2nd quarter and started to loosen up, he started to doing some playmaking himself. Of course, on the very next play Gilbert missed an open Mike Davis for what should have been a sure 20-yard touchdown, so it wasn't all pretty, but in terms of his comfort level and confidence, this seemed to mark a turning point in Saturday night's game.
Next up: The fly sweep to Jaxon Shipley.
27 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Thank you for taking the time to do this PB.
This is a great breakdown of the play and a good one for Gilbert. But to me it’s just that. One play. I saw too much last night that did not give me hope. Throwing low to his receivers. Staring down his first option. Inexplicably throwing to his receiver who is two yards short of the sticks on 3rd down. Turning and throwing a screen pass and not noticing that the ball would be better thrown at the RB’s feet because the screen has already been blown up. Not throwing the ball away to avoid the sack. And most disturbing of all throwing the ball backwards to avoid a sack.
Gilbert is the same QB as last year. Only things that have changed are system and upgrades in personnel at RB, OL, and WR. There is no upgrade at QB.
Do not be distracted by what you see, but be transformed by what you believe.
Agreed.
I’d just have more fun if I saw David Ash run the fourth quarter.
Gilbert didn’t look right against Rice.
I just can’t, without much pain, picture how he’ll look against OU.
Why so excited about Ash?
He could be good, or he could be bad. Why not get up for some development by Gilbert and McCoy?
QB Garrett Gilbert was the Beavis & Butthead episode of the 2010 college football season. Even when things were going well there was always one bad decision that meant he wasn’t going to score.
http://cfn.scout.com/2/1070636.html
by burntorangehorn on Sep 5, 2011 10:18 AM CDT up reply actions
The most popular quarterback at Texas?
The one who isn’t playing.
Greg Davis haikus; a lot like his offenses; always go sideways.
by pleaseplaykindle on Sep 5, 2011 2:30 PM CDT up reply actions 1 recs
I can't remember which announcer/analyst said it
But one once said, “The fans’ favorite player on the team is usually the backup quarterback.”
QB Garrett Gilbert was the Beavis & Butthead episode of the 2010 college football season. Even when things were going well there was always one bad decision that meant he wasn’t going to score.
http://cfn.scout.com/2/1070636.html
by burntorangehorn on Sep 5, 2011 4:24 PM CDT up reply actions
Last year was enough...
…development time for GG. He’s either got it or not. McCoy does not have the physical attributes. That leaves Ash, and he should get real minutes to play as a real QB.
Let GG keep starting, and hopefully he’ll improve, but it’s absurd to claim he needs more development time beyond what he’s getting already as the starter.
+2
Gilbert did not show me much improvement. He just has better receivers. As pointed out he took 2 sacks he did not have to take. Plus I his fumble on one of the sacks was luckily recovered by his RB. His play vs a real team would have been worse and BYU will expose him next week.
His only defense is that IMO the OL needs to work hard this week. They let the pocket collapse too quickly too often. GG reminds me of David Carr when I prefer he look more like Aaron Rogers who was an amazing QB even two years ago when his OL was horrible.
I'm slightly optimistic
Like Peter, I saw improvement as the game went on. After the train wreck of last year, just getting through the first game without an interception was progress. While I lost the feed before the end, I don’t recall seeing any batted balls, which drove me crazy last year.
Let’s see how things progress in the next few weeks.
.
by Longhorn in Canada on Sep 4, 2011 11:47 PM CDT reply actions
Peter
I haven’t had a chance to look yet, because I haven’t been home since the game, and TYT is blocked at work. Is that where you found the file?
By the way, this has been my favorite series of posts from the past 2 years. Really glad to see it make a comeback. Hook em!
Eight Walls a new MMA blog from Fantake
Follow me on Twitter
Follow Eight Walls on Twitter
SECede?....Whoop(s)!!
I thought Gilbert had a strong showing last night
We had at least four drops between the receivers and TEs and Gilbert will get his timing down on the Davis fly route in time. His ability to stretch the defense vertically is vastly underrated and it makes sense why he is the clear choice over McCoy.
I remember this play explicitly
because I remember thinking “A rusher from a school other than Rice would have gotten the sack.”
I really hope I’m being too cynical.
Proud adoptee of Dick Tidrow the mastermind behind Tim Lincecum, Matt Cain, Buster Posey and many more. Also known as "The Reason".
Thanks for the Snap-shot posts, PB. Very nice....
along the lines of Longhorn Scott’s excellent series on BC using video to illustrate the mechanics of Harsin’s offense.
I wonder if the anti-GG sentiment is a remnant of the requirement for transcendent, improvisational QB play that the old repetetive, simplistic, predictable Greg Davis offense required. Vince and Colt were masterful at that and GG simply isn’t that kind of player. Many seem to resent him intensely for that and think he is therefore hopeless as a QB.
Like you, I suspect he can improve, particularly running an offense that doesn’t ask him to be something he isn’t. It will also help him immensely to have better OL, WR and RB play around him. As Mack apparently reminded him before the game—he doesn’t have to win it by himself.
GG was hopeless trying to be VY or Colt. Fortunately, Harsin’s offense won’t require that of him. I think he can run Harsin’s offense competently and that we will see him improve in that capacity with repetitions.
I'll take 10 yards per pass attempt
If we can run the football, keep defenses off balance, GG will be fine.
Agree
At Texas, we’re so used to thinking that the QB needs to be an improvisational hero/savior (in order to compensate for an inept scheme and execution thereof). Harsin’s offense is sound enough such that the QB need only be a competent role player. And based on what I saw Saturday night (stupid backward toss aside), I think GG can be an excellent role player, particularly if we know that’s his ceiling and don’t ask him to do anything beyond it.
I don't think GD's offense required that
Of course it made the offense better than it would’ve been with lesser guys, and better than it was with Simms, Applewhite, or Mock, but a transcendent QB wasn’t absolutely required for a team to succeed. GD wasn’t perfect, but the notion that his offense hinged on having superman at QB doesn’t acknowledge Colt’s physical limitations and VY’s youthful imperfections, as well as the low-quality OL and RB play (probably stemming from poor positional coaching, for the most part).
QB Garrett Gilbert was the Beavis & Butthead episode of the 2010 college football season. Even when things were going well there was always one bad decision that meant he wasn’t going to score.
http://cfn.scout.com/2/1070636.html
by burntorangehorn on Sep 5, 2011 4:28 PM CDT up reply actions
Ehh I don't know man.
Saturday I watched a team roll up 500 yards of offense doing nothing nothing particular spectacular. I was floored to see that we’d run up 500+ yards. And the principle reason? All those -2 and -3 yard plays under GD were +2 and +3 yard plays under AppleSin.
GD loved to talk about “explosive” plays. These are exactly the plays that, as an OC, you shouldn’t rely on because they’re infrequent, risky, and require supernatural talent at skill positions to execute consistently. Instead, AppleSin seem to focus on positive yards every play. I mean, how many times on Saturday did our offense lose yardage as compared to last year?
/reading too much into the Rice game
Greg Davis haikus; a lot like his offenses; always go sideways.
by pleaseplaykindle on Sep 5, 2011 7:06 PM CDT up reply actions
I definitely agree that this first game was a big improvement
Especially in comparison to last year. But really, compare it to almost any UT-Rice game with GD prior to 2010, and the output looks normal-ish. Very few negative-yardage plays.
QB Garrett Gilbert was the Beavis & Butthead episode of the 2010 college football season. Even when things were going well there was always one bad decision that meant he wasn’t going to score.
http://cfn.scout.com/2/1070636.html
by burntorangehorn on Sep 5, 2011 7:22 PM CDT up reply actions
Just like what Colt did Starting his Jr year, GG needs to run more...
I think the threat of that alone will open up some options for the offense.
GG seemed to loosen up after that run
Considering how many mistakes he makes when he presses, it may be worth it call a few QB draws or run options just to get him to relax earlier on.
Enjoyed the play selection and Gilbert's execution
I felt the following illustrated this: There was a long pass to Davis which went for an incompletion. Many in the stands around me comnplained about Gilber’s not hitting the receiver after Davis had beaten the safety long.
(These are the same types who believe that Malcolm Brown should have started and never left the game once in; that Whitaker played a poor game; and the defense which did not allow a TD looked terrible. These fans are the ones which give UT such a poor name for arrogance. How i wish they would become Aggies or Sooners. But enough of my rant.)
While i would have liked to see this completed (like two others he threw) I explained to my wife that often simply the threat of making a long completion sets up passes underneath because the safeties start to play further back. Before i could complete my explanation Gilbert was delivering to Shipley for a nice 15-20 gainer in front of retreating safeties. This is the type of play calling which builds on suceesful plays as well as ones which are unsuccessful at the intial blush.
Pardon the typos. Where is the splchec?
All new states are infested, more or less, by a class of noisy, second-rate men who are always in favor of rash and extreme measures, but Texas was absolutely overrun by such men. --Sam Houston--
by Tex34xas on Sep 5, 2011 1:21 PM CDT reply actions 2 recs
+1
I love football smart FANS…
by French-Horn on Sep 5, 2011 3:52 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
The play selection was great
I felt like every player on our offense was dangerous. We’re using everyone. It’s just great. I feel like they’ve really taken some pressure off the line and Gilbert by using a real running attack and sweeps.
Gilbert was 2/3 on those long bombs and was maybe a foot off on the one he missed. He made a good play with his feet, and had no interceptions. Nice work, in my book. Something we can build on.
I thought the O-Line was stressed in clear passing or clear running situations… I think our season hangs on them.
Don't forget that pass to Shipley
which was a great play call made him come to his knees because it was such low throw and prevented any YAC.
Do not be distracted by what you see, but be transformed by what you believe.
This play is a good example of the Rice D-Line getting the better of our O-Line
This play wasn’t even recorded as a QB hurry in the stat line which includes only 1 QB hurry and 2 sacks.
The biggest hope I had for this game was not seeing Rice in the backfield. I hope HarsinWhite have the trickeration needed to work around this.
I want to see Ash throw a deep ball!
I know Gilbert can throw a nice one. McCoy has no hope of throwing one.
It will be important to see how Gilbert recovers from his mistakes in a game. He did recover nicely from that stupid backward lateral. I’ll be really interested to see how he responds after throwing an INT. Will he be Favre-esque and throws another soon after? Or will he learn from it and grow? That’s the key to him.
"Football's so important in Texas. On the West Coast, it's a social. On the East Coast, it's a culture. Here, it's a religion."
-- Major Applewhite
Ash throwing a deep ball?
Gimme.
Eight Walls a new MMA blog from Fantake
Follow me on Twitter
Follow Eight Walls on Twitter
SECede?....Whoop(s)!!

by 






































