End Of Year MaxwellPundit Award Ballot
Once more, our ballot in the MaxwellPundit Award voting, as presented by and hosted at The Rakes Of Mallow.
Remember: voting is open to players of any age, at any position.
1. Reggie Nelson, Safety, Florida Gators There's a lot I dislike about today's college football coverage on television - starting with the human beings being paid to talk during the broadcasts. One truly wondrous development, though, is those outstanding floating cameras that shoot film from just over the action on the field. When they replay a down from that floating angle, you get a reasonable facsimile of what the quarterback saw as he dropped back to pass.
On Monday night, every time we saw what Troy Smith saw, there was Reggie Nelson leading his secondary to blanket coverage of the Buckeye receivers. Dudes were just never open. As crappy as Ohio State's line was - and they were bad - the Florida secondary was smothering, too. Nelson was a huge reason why. There weren't any big numbers for Nelson to have because the Buckeyes could not move the football. The guy's a monster.
2. Patrick Willis, LB, Ole Miss Here's your rightful Bronko Nagurski winner. Led the SEC in tackles, hit like a ton of bricks, while starting all twelve games. He's gonna make a whale of a professional and - if he's not a top ten pick - be the steal of the draft.
3. Calvin Johnson, WR, Georgia Tech Sucks for Johnson that he wasted his talent with Reggie Ball. But he did. Probably the #1 overall talent in this year's draft class. Just unbelievably gifted. Reminds me of Terrell Owens during his best years. But sane.
4. LaMarr Woodley, DE, Michigan Who's better? Woodley or Branch? Aw, who cares? Both were elite. Woodley finished with 12 sacks and helped Michigan's line dominate at a near-record level.
5. Colt Brennan, QB, Hawaii Mel Kiper says he's a "system" guy. Whatever, Mel. He still had - what - 80 touchdowns? Okay, 58. And he threw for five touchdowns against Boise State! They are a good football team, no? Brennan's numbers are inflated, yes, but when you're pretty much doubling up the rest of the field, this is more than just floating through the system. You're playing great, great football.
--PB--
0 recs |
7 comments
Comments
Calvin Johnson
Reggie Ball kind of reminded me of Reggie McNeal. They both talked a lot of trash and put up good numbers against bad team. They also had one marquee win. Reggie vs. Auburn and McNeal vs. OU.
Anyways Calvin Johnson what a monster you really couldn't guard that guy. Everybody knew the ball was going to go to him and yet they couldn't stop him. I really didn't understand why they didn't just throw him "horizontal passes" all the time.
There was no other candidate that was impressive as CJ. Nelson is the only one that comes close but he played so deep that he didn't make any plays in the run game and i could get a million picks playing that deep. He was more a product of scheme that the coaches put out there. If our safties played that deep we probably would have been in the Fiesta Bowl. But our linebackers suck so they have to be in run support.
No comments on Colt Brennan he is a system guy and thats that just like every Tech qb and Hawaii qb. If they get a bum of the street he could probably throw for a thousand yards.
Willis is probably the most underrated player there just a sideline to sideline freak but plays on a shitty Ole Miss team. Where's Eli?
Woodley is unblockable but he is a d-linemen and in his biggest game didn't really do much. Don't talk about Notre Dame as a big game. I could sack Brady Quinn with the bad line. He is probably the scariest player there just a freak of nature.
Hands down its Calvin Johnson and no contest. If he had a competent qb like Colt McCoy or hell Jamarcus Russell he would be the greatest college player besides my boy VY.
by txlonghorn on Jan 12, 2007 12:30 AM CST reply actions 0 recs
Two things
Second, the breaks make your good commentary very readable, and there's lots of good stuff in there.
I do tend to agree that Calvin is THE man, but we won't -quite- know the extent of his prowess until he gets a real QB. And I so agree, obviously - Reggie Ball is just AWFUL.
by Peter Bean on Jan 12, 2007 12:33 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Reggie Ball
Patrick Willis is the best player nobody saw the last four years. I'd go with Calvin, too, but I'd put Willis a lot closer.
by beast in bama on Jan 12, 2007 5:27 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Thanks
by txlonghorn on Jan 12, 2007 12:52 AM CST reply actions 0 recs
Technically speaking
Let's keep that growth going - in all areas.
by Peter Bean on Jan 12, 2007 12:55 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Award Idea
by Wells on Jan 12, 2007 2:50 PM CST reply actions 0 recs























