Burnt Orange Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Spencer Hall's Sports Meme Power Rankings

More BlogPoll Confusion: Explain Yourselves!

As mentioned this morning, this week's BlogPoll is out. For all the time we bloggers spend carping about rankings among coaches and voters who do not take seriously enough their charge, there remain some headscratching results among the BlogPoll consensus.

Take yesterday's comparison between Texas and Michigan. There's a rather interesting question to be answered regarding how much to penalize the Wolverines for a horrific loss, as well as how much to penalize Texas for no substantive wins. How much should we value Michigan's recent wins against their bad losses? Has Texas done enough to justify a ranking at all?

However you resolve those questions, I'm left looking at the poll and wondering how Auburn is ranked behind either team. I'll be conservative and put Mississippi State in the "bad loss" category, though they're not quite the whipping posts they've been in recent years.  Even so, take a look:

The justification for placing Auburn behind Texas is beyond me. Auburn has Texas whipped in quality wins; Texas has matched Auburn in bad losses, and Auburn has one more loss only because it's played two teams (LSU and South Florida) who are far superior to anyone Texas has faced in 2007 outside of Oklahoma. Hell, there's even a common opponent (KSU) who Auburn defeated and Texas fell flat. All told, the more you look at Texas' body of work, the more difficult it becomes to place Texas on the ballot at all.

As for Michigan? Auburn has a win at Florida which spanks the Wolverines' top win. The intermediate stuff is roughly equal. The only case for dinging Auburn is the home loss to Mississippi State, but if you want to penalize harshly for that kind of loss, it has to be uniform. There would be no basis for not applying it to Michigan as well.

Anyone?

--PB--

0 recs  |  Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Re:

It's Mississippi State. MSU is ranked 11th in the SEC Blog Power Poll. Besides its win against Auburn, MSU's wins have come at Tulane (2-5 overall, 4th in the C-USA west), UAB (2-5 overall, 5th in the C-USA east) and Gardner-Webb (3-4 in I-AA). Granted, MSU's 4 losses have come against ranked teams, but none of them were particularly close. MSU ranks #95 in scoring offense, #74 in rushing offense and #113 in passing offense. They rank #63 in scoring defense, #65 in passing defense and #18 in passing defense.

To put that into context, Iowa State ranks #116, #87, and #85 on offense, and #86, #39 and #67 on defense, in respective categories. Nebraska ranks #63, #66, #29 and #91, #115, #70. Colorado ranks #77, #82, #45 and #48, #35, #34.

If I were ranking, I'd put MSU somewhere better than Iowa State but not as good as Colorado (or maybe even Nebraska). Thus, the MSU loss is something that sticks on voters' minds when it comes to Auburn. Combine that with them just picking up their 3rd loss (and no arguing that they were close to beating LSU...just the previous week, they were close to losing to Arkansas), and you can see why voters are hesitant to raise them that high.

Auburn, like Texas, will have a chance to raise its ranking solely by beating up on bad teams (they play Ole Miss and Tennessee Tech their next two games) before closing out the season with a couple of toughies (at Georgia, Alabama), so it may be a while before we see how good this Auburn team truly is.

My adopted kid is pure genius at the Black-Scholes Option Pricing Model.

by jc25 on Oct 24, 2007 3:11 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Definition of bad loss
How can a loss to a tier 2 team be a bad loss?  Is it because of the margin?  Oregon is a good football team and currently ranked 5th in the country so I'm not sure a loss to them is bad, definitely not as bad as a loss to Appy State or Miss State.

by jthorn on Oct 24, 2007 4:48 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I would say...
any loss by 32 points is a bad loss...
Roy Miller - with the possible exception of Barbara Feldon, the best #99 anywhere!!!

by agent orange on Oct 24, 2007 4:58 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

It's the margin and that it was at home

Losing to Oregon is nothing to be ashamed of. Getting waxed at home is bad, though.

--PB--

by Peter Bean on Oct 24, 2007 5:03 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Burnt Orange Nation, a blog dedicated to University of Texas athletics. Get BON updates via Twitter.
Start posting about the Longhorns »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

T1_1018_coltheisman_small
Texas vs UC Irvine Gameflow (+/- stats included)
Horns_small
Thanks to our Men & Women in the Armed Forces
Small
The Aggies are doing just enough this year to give us a good upset.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Ohio State and Oklahoma Uni's
Small
BCS Formula Question
2401104_1__small
The Perfect Storm of College Football
T1_1018_coltheisman_small
Texas vs Western Carolina Gameflow
Lemon_small
Pat Murphy resigns
Small
Orakpo says TCU can't hang
Clock_tower_small
The Weekly BON Hit Award Baylor
11-09_small
2009 Horns VS 2005 Horns....are we better? Equal? Worse?
Small
Vote for McCoy Saturday at Gate 25!
1994_brown_james_small
I am glad to say I've seen the greatest team of my lifetime...

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SPONSORS


Site Editors

Pb6_small Peter Bean

Dark_pumpkin_small awiggo

Menbooger_small GhostofBigRoy

Contributing Authors

Jersey_front_small 54b

Zombie_profilepic_small Horn Brain

Gse_multipart20834_small 40AS

Pigeons_small billyzane

Small whills

Brandedbevo1024x768_small dimecoverage

Rosebowl_small txtwstr7

Small TheElusiveShadow

Me_small burnt in ny

Official Partner of CBS Sports